Commentary by Tim Horrigan; September 5, 2008
|
You can download the flyer in PDF format from: The flyer urged its readers to visit this URL: |
I also urge everyone to visit my 2008 election pages:
|
Vice Presidential candidate Sarah Palin has taken a controversial stand in favor of Freedom, and she looks like a librarian— and yet she is notorious for pressuring her city library to ban a large number of books from the library, during her executive experience as Mayor of Wasilla, Alaska. Whatever Freedom means to her, it does not include freedom with a small "f" of thought.
Someone named Andrew AuCoin put together the following list, which was posted in various places including the blog Librarian.net. The provenance of the list is uncertain and Palin's apologists have been nitpicking it. Much was made of the fact that this book includes books written as recently as 2000 while Palin's executive experience began way back in 1996, in the last century. However, her executive experience as Mayor of Wasilla ran until 2002, and it is possible that she had a list of books she wanted banned in 1996, which she added to over the coming years. The claim that she totally dropped this issue after 1996 is hard to swallow: Palin is after all a "pit bull with lipstick" who is not a flipflopper and who would rather lose an election than lose a war (any war, even a cultural war.)
Palin is notorious for being in favor of the notorious Bridge to Nowhere before she was against it. On the other hand, she was always in favor of banning books from the Wasilla Public Library. Happily, she was unsuccessful in getting the books banned: one of the reasons she failed was because libraries, like most local public services in Alaska, are actually provided at the Borough (county) level.
AuCoin said "This is the list
of books Palin tried to have banned. As many of you will notice
it is
a hit parade for book burners." AuCoin's list had 90
entries, but Huckleberry
Finn
was counted twice.
Even though I am busy with my
own 2008 State Representative campaign, I have taken the
time to
put together Amazon.com
links to each of the 89 books.
[Sept.
11,
2008: the provenance of the list is no longer uncertain. A page
on the website of a "book packaging" called Adler &
Robin Books has the exact same list. Adler
&
Robin's web page— whose URL is:
http://www.adlerbooks.com/banned.html—
is dated September 2004 and is identical to AuCoin's list, right
down
to the errors of including The
Adventures of Huckleberry Finn twice and the misspelling
of
"Harry
Potter
and the Prisoner of Azkaban"
as "Harry
Potter
and the Prizoner
of
Azkaban
.
Also, the current Mayor Of Wasilla, Dianne M. Keller— the woman
who
presumably is on her way to becoming the second female Vice
President
of the United States— issued a press
release on September 9 stating that no books have ever
been
banned from the library. Keller claims that only one book was
challenged during Sarah Palin's executive experience— Heather
Has Two Mommies by Leslea Newman
—
but it was not removed from the shelves. The press release
doesn't
say who challenged it.]
Anyway, here is the list:
My Brother Sam Is Dead by James Lincoln
Collier and Christopher Collier
One Day in The Life of Ivan Denisovich by
Alexander Solzhenitsyn
Our Bodies, Ourselves by the Boston Woman's
Health Collective
Scary Stories 3: More Tales to Chill Your
Bones by Alvin Schwartz
The New Teenage Body Book by Kathy McCoy and
Charles Wibbelsman
Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary by
the Merriam-Webster Editorial Staff
Witches, Pumpkins, and Grinning Ghosts: The
Story of the Halloween Symbols by Edna Barth
See
Also:
Gov.
Sarah Palin dedicating a bridge to somewhere (Nenana, AK),
August 9,
2008.